LOUISVILLE, Ky. — Five months after Jefferson County Public Schools (JCPS) announced plans to conduct racial equity reviews on mascots and school names, at least four public schools in Louisville have begun the process of making changes.

What You Need To Know

  • The Jefferson County Board of Education asked schools to review mascots and names last September

  • The reviews are being done to ensure the names and mascots are “culturally appropriate and culturally responsible”

  • Four schools have begun the process of making changes

  • Atherton and Seneca are making mascot-related changes while Thomas Jefferson Middle School and the J. Graham Brown School may change their names

Last fall, administrators at Atherton High School said the school would retire its rebel mascot and officials at Seneca High School removed imagery of its former mascot, a Native American figure, from around the school. 

Thomas Jefferson Middle School and The J. Graham Brown School have also had “discussions” about changing their names, JCPS spokesperson Renee Murphy said. More schools could join them. 

“Schools are still going through the process and making sure the images seen in the school are reflective of what we want to convey — if they're culturally appropriate and culturally responsible,” Murphy said. 

The effort to review the school names and mascots was announced in an early September meeting of the Jefferson County Board of Education. 

"If we find mascots and other things that are marginalizing or muting students of color voices, then that will be changed," JCPS Chief Equity Officer John Marshall said at the time. 

The announcement came at a tense time in Louisville, which had seen three consecutive months of protests against the police killing of Breonna Taylor. Demonstrators demanded justice for the 26-year-old former EMT, but they also made calls for equity in the city. The mascot and school name review is one small answer to those calls.

“We want our students to know that we are an equitable institution,” Murphy said. “We want to make sure that our practices are reflective of our population. And we want our students to have experiences that are diverse in nature.”

Thirty-six percent of JCPS students are Black, while Louisville is 23% Black. 

The evaluation process

When the board called on district schools to evaluate their mascots and names, they gave them a tool called the Racial Equity Analysis Protocol (REAP) to perform the task. The protocol is routinely used to evaluate programs, procedures, and initiatives within the district. REAP requires those conducting an analysis to answer questions about a proposal’s likelihood of perpetuating racial inequities, potential unintended consequences, and the populations most affected. 

"The purpose of the REAP is to make sure as you are making decisions for our students and our families. We have no unintended consequences that disproportionately impacts our students of color," Marshall said in a video explaining the REAP on the district’s website.

Murphy said the questions on the REAP help people "think about the policies, practices, procedures that are in place and if they're truly equitable." After the questions are answered, those conducting the REAP are supposed to ask questions of themselves, including, "After using the REAP for this program or practice, should it move forward?"

Where change is coming

In October of last year, Atherton High School, known as the rebels since the 1950s, announced plans to change its mascot. According to a school newsletter from 2015, the name was not originally a reference to confederate rebels, despite the school’s later use of the Confederate Flag in depictions of the mascot. Rather, it was chosen by the field hockey team that formed in defiance of the principal. In the 70s, depictions of the rebel were changed to make him look like a revolutionary war-era rebel. 

Seneca High School became the Redhawks in the 90s, but depictions of the old mascot were removed just last year. (Spectrum News 1/Adam K. Raymond)

Seneca High School went through a similar process in the 90s, when its name was changed from Redskins, a derogatory slur for Native Americans, to Redhawks. Murphy said the school worked this fall to remove a few depictions of the old mascot that were “still lingering in their buildings.” 

While the mascot can be changed at the school-level, changing a school’s name requires action from the board. The two schools whose leaders have expressed interest in a name change honor Thomas Jefferson and J. Graham Brown.

In July, the school-based decision-making council (SBDM) at Thomas Jefferson Middle School submitted a name change proposal to the board. And in late September, following the board’s call for school to evaluate their names, the J. Graham Brown School's SBDM, made up of teachers and parents, agreed that a name change is in order.

Jefferson, the third president of the United States, owned more than 600 slaves in his lifetime. Brown, who owned downtown Louisville’s Brown Hotel, resisted attempts to desegregate in the 1960s, leading to sit-ins from local activists. 

The list of JCPS schools named for historic figures with ties to racism is longer than two though. Watterson Elementary is named for Confederate soldier Henry Watterson, Zachary Taylor Elementary is named for another former president who owned slaves, and Foster Traditional Academy is named for the songwriter Stephen Foster whose work includes “My Old Kentucky Home,” the 1853 minstrel song that has long drawn criticism for its lyrics.

For more coverage on Black History Month please visit our special section