FRANKFORT, Ky. — Kentucky’s Supreme Court on Thursday refused to allow abortions to resume in the state, rejecting a request to halt enforcement of a near-total ban on abortion that has largely been in place since Roe v. Wade was overturned.
What You Need To Know
- Kentucky’s Supreme Court on Thursday refused to allow abortions to resume in the state, rejecting a request to halt enforcement of a near-total ban on abortion
- The court, which was weighing challenges to the state’s near-total ban and a separate one that outlaws abortion after the sixth week of pregnancy, sent the case back to a lower court for further consideration of constitutional issues related to one of the bans
- The court weighed in on the issue after Kentucky voters last year rejected a ballot measure that would have denied any constitutional protections for abortion
- Kentucky’s near-total trigger law ban was passed in 2019 and took effect when the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade
The court, which was weighing challenges to the state’s near-total ban and a separate one that outlaws abortion after the sixth week of pregnancy, sent the case back to a lower court for further consideration of constitutional issues related to one of the bans.
The court weighed in on the issue after Kentucky voters last year rejected a ballot measure that would have denied any constitutional protections for abortion. The Republican-led Legislature passed both of those laws.
“To be clear, this opinion does not in any way determine whether the Kentucky Constitution protects or does not protect the right to receive an abortion, as no appropriate party to raise that issue is before us.” Deputy Chief Justice Debra Hembree Lambert wrote. “Nothing in this opinion shall be construed to prevent an appropriate party from filing suit at a later date.”
The challenges revolve around the state's near-total trigger law ban and the separate six-week ban. The trigger law was passed in 2019 and took effect when the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade. It bans abortions except when they’re carried out to save the life of the mother or to prevent disabling injury. It does not include exceptions for cases of rape or incest.
Attorney General Daniel Cameron's office released a statement shortly after the ruling broke, expressing pleasure that the high court allowed the abortion restrictions to remain in place. "This is a significant victory, and we will continue to stand up for the unborn by defending these laws," Cameron said.
In July, Louisville judge Mitch Perry halted enforcement of the new bans because he found that they likely violated the state constitution’s rights to privacy and self-determination. He said it wasn’t the court’s role to determine whether the state constitution guarantees the right to abortion, but it is its role to decide whether the new bans violate constitutionally guaranteed freedoms.
But the state Court of Appeals reinstated enforcement of the bans and the state Supreme Court opted in August to keep them in place while it reviewed the case.
On Thursday, the high court ruled that the two Louisville abortion providers that challenged the near-total and six-week bans on the argument that they violated patients' constitutional rights lacked the “third-party standing" to do so.
Lambert, though, wrote that the abortion providers have “first-party” constitutional standing to challenge the trigger ban, specifically. As a result, the justices sent that part of the case back to the circuit court in Louisville to review the plaintiffs' claims that the trigger ban violated the state constitution.
Addia Wuchner, executive director of Kentucky Right to Life, was attending a rally for Faith and Family Day steps away from the Kentucky Supreme Court when the court released its ruling.
"We are elated in the ruling,” she said. "We still have work to do, but for right now, the facilities in Kentucky remain closed. We are at day 198 without effectively having abortions taking place here in the commonwealth of Kentucky.”
The ACLU of Kentucky expressed "extreme disappointment" with the Kentucky Supreme Court's latest ruling.
"Once again, the Kentucky Supreme Court failed to protect the health and safety of nearly a million people in the state," leaders from Planned Parenthood and the ACLU said in a statement. "Even after Kentuckians overwhelmingly voted against an anti-abortion ballot measure, abortion remains banned in the state."
Angela Cooper, communications director of ACLU of Kentucky, added, “Unfortunately, it does mean that abortion care cannot resume in the state of Kentucky at this time,” said Cooper. "However, the ruling was very clear in that it was not a decision on whether the constitution does or does not protect the right to an abortion in Kentucky so that argument is still on the table.”
Thirteen states have current bans on abortion at all stages of pregnancy, including Wisconsin, where there’s a legal question over which law is in effect but where clinics have shut down. Bans and tight restrictions are currently on hold because of court action in at least six states.